Last Updated on 3 November 2023
I searched the Internet for lists of the best episodes of The Simpsons. Criteria included the episodes being ranked, not just listed and generally created by groups, whether teams or committees or based on general public voting (like Ranker.com).
I found 28 different ranked lists online of “best Simpsons episodes.” Then I averaged the rankings each episode got and divided that average by a factor of the number of lists that episode was on. The lowest score meant a high ranking average on many lists. The complete spreadsheet is attached at the bottom.
The episodes that were on the most lists (out of 28):
- Marge vs. the Monorail (S4 E12) – 27 lists
- Cape Feare (S5 E2) – 23 lists
- Mr. Plow (S4 E9) – 23 lists
- You Only Move Twice (S8 E2) – 21 lists
- Last Exit to Springfield (S4 E17) – 19 lists
- 22 Short Films About Springfield (S7 E21) – 19 lists
- Who Shot Mr. Burns? (Part One) (S6 E25) – 18 lists
- Homer at the Bat (S3 E17) – 17 lists
- Rosebud (S5 E4) – 17 lists
- Deep Space Homer (S5 E15) – 17 lists
Here are links to the lists I used:
- Ranker – 1 Nov 2023
- Episode Ninja – 30 Oct 2023
- CBR – 7 Oct 2023
- Collider – 16 Sep 2023
- IGN – 13 Jul 2023
- ONE37pm – 3 Jul 2023
- Digital Trends – 9 Jun 2023
- Kotaku – 7 Apr 2023
- The Manual – 9 Mar 2023
- RadioX – 17 Dec 2022
- Cultured Vulture – 10 Jun 2022
- Entertainment Weekly – 2 Jun 2022
- WriteBase – 17 May 2022
- The Nerd Stash – 24 Apr 2022
- GameRant/IMDb – 10 Dec 2021
- Variety Magazine – 8 Dec 2021
- The Independent – 20 Mar 2020
- Average Joes – 13 Feb 2020
- Newsweek – 17 Dec 2019
- Rolling Stone – 17 Dec 2019
- Time Magazine – 16 Dec 2019
- Vulture – 19 Nov 2019
- The Ringer – 17 Apr 2017
- Entertainment.ie – 17 Dec 2014
- Waiting for Next Year – 29 Oct 2014
- Complex – 17 Feb 2012
- Vanity Fair – 5 Jul 2007
- The Top Tens – no date